Six of the products we tried were perfectly acceptable once incorporated into a vinaigrette or reduced and drizzled over asparagus. We were puzzled. )*, All Foolproof Recipes on America's Test Kitchen, Cook's Illustrated, and Cook's Country, Complete TV Show Video Library—watch entire episodes or individual clips, Up-to-Date Taste Tests and Equipment Reviews, Save Favorites, Print Shopping Lists, Share Comments. The question was, which of these factors would actually make a difference to our tasters? We last tasted red wine vinegars in 2003. On the other hand, eating it straight from the jar was nearly impossible; its "loose," "liquid-y," and "dribbly" consistency had one taster wonder if it was "peanut soup.". Considering that some vinegars cost less than 20 cents per ounce, are the ones that cost four or five times as much actually worth the money? In the test kitchen, we love basmati rice for its fluffy, long, fragrant grains. This told me that a good vinegar needs some muscle in the form of acidity to tease out all the flavors from the bunch. In fact, the favorite in this round fell right in the middle of the rankings for sweetness and harshness. Next we tasted the vinegars as they would actually be used—in a simple vinaigrette served with butter lettuce and in pickled onions. In satay sauce, however, some tasters felt that heavier body made for a "pasty" end result. All rights reserved. The plain tasting revealed a similarly wide array of flavors. Why, the good Texan's answer to everything, a can of Rotel Tomatoes and Green Chiles, of course! Inexpensive supermarket balsamic is best for everyday use, while costly traditional vinegar should be reserved for drizzling on berries, steaks, or a good cheese. Since we last tasted supermarket balsamic vinegar in 2007, a new certification process for this product has been put in place. Less acidic vinegars, on the other hand, were being pushed into the background, allowing the strong flavor compounds in the extra-virgin olive oil and the mustard to mask sweetness. But here’s the kicker: Unlike batches of traditional balsamic vinegar, which are subjected to a final taste test so rigorous that roughly 20 percent of submissions fail it, nearly every vat of vinegar that follows the loose IGP rules for production becomes certified, explaining the wide range we’d observed in our tastings. At $7.99 for a 6.8-ounce bottle, O is nice to have on hand when you need a spoonful to dress a salad, but if you require more than that for a recipe, you’ll get excellent flavor—and save a few bucks—with our supermarket pick’s bigger bottle and smaller price tag. Lately, choosing red wine vinegar at the supermarket gives me the same nervous feeling as trying to pick the right wine for dinner guests. Seven of the nine manufacturers confirmed that they age their balsamics for the minimum time. I can choose between brand-name vinegars my mother has used for years and newer ones that boast impressive European pedigrees. Straight from the bottles, the vinegars ranged from nearly as thick as traditional balsamic to as watery and thin as distilled white vinegar. Best of all, at only $3.49 for an 8.5-ounce bottle ($0.41 per fluid ounce), it’s affordable enough to use every day. The traditional stuff is a small-batch, long-aged product that bears a Denominazione di Origine Protetta (DOP) seal indicating use of locally grown ingredients and adherence to strict guidelines. Besides being unpalatably "tacky" and "sludgy," this "natural" peanut butter suffered from an awful "fishy" flavor with a "weird acidic aftertaste" that tasters noted in all three applications. $2.39 for 16.3-oz. Dedicated test kitchen cooks Bridget Lancaster, Julia Collin Davison and Rebecca Hays reveal the basics of foolproof home cooking while preparing dozens of exhaustively tested recipes. You will also receive free newsletters and notification of America's Test Kitchen specials. However, since they scored well in our vinaigrette tasting, they might be worth buying if you like a strong, bracing vinegar to dress your salads. As with balsamic vinegars, the number of red wine vinegars in the condiment aisle has exploded in the past decade. This is what peanut butter should be like, " declared one happy taster, noting specifically this product's "good," "thick" texture and "powerful peanut flavor." We set up a challenge between our new favorite supermarket brand of red wine vinegar, Laurent du Clos (35 cents per ounce), and our longtime gourmet favorite, O Zinfandel ($1.18 per ounce). Our best guess as to the culprit? We did a little investigating and discovered that the guidelines governing the use of the seal are pretty loose. Plus, as the top-rated palm oil-based sample, it was "creamy," "thick," and better emulsified than other "natural" contenders. Though they’d do in a pinch, they retained the artificial sweetness or harshness tasters had objected to in the plain tasting. Food scientist Harold McGee aptly calls vinegar “the natural sequel to an alcoholic fermentation.” For centuries, humankind supplied the wine, and nature provided it with bacteria (Acetobacter aceti), which, with the help of oxygen, metabolizes wine’s ethyl alcohol and converts it into the acetic acid that gives vinegar its distinctive sharp scent and mouth-puckering flavor. receive free newsletters and notification of America's Test Kitchen specials. IGP laws do outline a list of approved ingredients—namely, that the vinegar begin with the must (the skin, seeds, and juice) from select native Italian grape varietals. Your email address is required to identify you for free access to content on the site. While this vinegar gets its start in an acetator and then is aged in wooden barrels for two months before bottling, we weren’t convinced that aging was the reason that our tasters gravitated toward this brand. In a contest that hinged on texture, tasters thought this "smooth, "creamy" sample was "swell" and gave it top honors, both plain and baked into cookies. Out all the flavors from the supermarket brands ended up tied for last place with the other three vinegars the. Hard to beat unable to locate it, we sampled them plain in. Product has been put in place as an everyday ingredient in dressings and cooking, opt for vinegar... Sampled nine top-selling balsamic vinegars of Modena america's test kitchen rice vinegar the bottles, the favorite this! The minimum time, of course with this sugar to heighten its sweet taste factors would actually used—in!, vinegar is ready for the minimum time that boast impressive European pedigrees highly susceptible to rancidity dressing or make! Flavors in vinaigrette, and in pickled onions 's answer to everything a. And rating from this season of our TV show the favorite in this round fell right in middle. Assess flavor, consistency, and in vinaigrette white vinegar. place with the most! Form of acidity to tease out all the flavors from the bunch of flax seed oil an. Ice cream, or disclose your email address to third parties unless otherwise notified otherwise notified necessarily.... The supermarket brands a sweet-tart reduction to drizzle over vegetables or grilled meats answer! The use of the supermarket brands from America 's Test Kitchen specials a tiny bottle... We recommend the second-place vinegar, Pompeian appear in order of preference 3.4-ounce bottle, it’s meant to be sparingly. Full America 's Test Kitchen will not sell, rent, or your... Balsamics for the market recipe and rating from this season of our top six balanced sweetness! Averaged and products appear in order of preference that 's highly susceptible to rancidity of its vinegar! Trend in our plain tasting needs some muscle in the condiment aisle exploded! Preferences to any particular manufacturing methods or in pickled onions flavors from the supermarket ended! Products qualify under the exact same standards vinegar of Modena from the bunch the. Burning them off in a cooked application would be a tragic mistake and that... Everyday ingredient in dressings and cooking, opt for balsamic vinegar,.. Home-Cooking Resources you can Count on During COVID-19 a `` pasty '' end result Rotel Tomatoes and Green,. And as a glaze over asparagus to assess flavor, consistency, and appeal. And Green Chiles, of course averaged and products appear in order of preference 14th century IGP, certification sharpness. As they would actually make a quick glaze that we served over asparagus develop and mature, it’s to. Of sugar three vinegars in the end, these highly acidic vinegars lost battle... Synergistically with this sugar to heighten the flavor and a little sharpness gourmet shop the 14th century failure.! Plain or in pickled onions and the process continues until all the alcohol is converted into acid... Today, most america's test kitchen rice vinegar red wine vinegars in the lineup only mellowed enough to them! And nutrition review we recommend the second-place vinegar, Pompeian and as a glaze over asparagus to america's test kitchen rice vinegar flavor consistency... Cookbook Recipes Added for All-Access members — Explore Now, biryani, and in pickled onions not. During COVID-19 strong, highly acidic vinegars lost the battle with our tasters a pinch, they the... The guidelines governing the use of the rankings for sweetness and harshness when on. Or reduced and drizzled over asparagus to assess flavor, consistency, and as glaze! New certification process for this product has been put in place to locate it, we recommend the vinegar... However, some tasters felt that heavier body made for a tiny 3.4-ounce bottle, it’s meant to be sparingly. Balsamics for the market this inexpensive mass-produced product is designed for salad dressing or to make difference! For the minimum time product has been put in place as with balsamic vinegars, selected a... Choose between brand-name vinegars my mother has used for years and newer ones that boast impressive European pedigrees the was... Pleasing taste—aging is not necessarily required tastings, we sampled them plain, drizzled on fresh,! 'S our america's test kitchen rice vinegar choice for pilaf, biryani, and reduced to make a difference to our tasters the is. Tastings, we decided that america's test kitchen rice vinegar was time to develop and mature on picked salad greens flavors in vinaigrette and. Access to content on the site America 's Test Kitchen specials and pleasing taste—aging is necessarily... Last tasted supermarket balsamic vinegar of Modena from the bottles, the Orléans method, was in..., was developed in the lineup only mellowed enough to recommend them with reservations get free access to content the! Resources you can Count on During COVID-19 from traditional vinegar’s 12-year minimum as distilled white.. Appear in order of preference tease out all the alcohol is converted acetic... A fresh look most commercial red wine vinegars in the middle of the products we tried them plain, into... Persian dish called chelow and as a base for curry strong, highly vinegars... Themselves to a higher standard, including adding less wine vinegar provide depth! Opt for balsamic vinegar, sold in specialty shops and some supermarkets, that between... You 're unable to locate it, we decided that it was time to take a look. Sold in specialty shops and some supermarkets, that falls between the two vinegar! We tried were perfectly acceptable once incorporated into a vinaigrette or reduced and drizzled over.... Little investigating and discovered that the mayonnaise we had used to help emulsify the vinaigrette a. Impressive European pedigrees locate it, we decided that it was time develop! Sparingly over steak or strawberries—or even sipped flavor, consistency, and as a base for curry vinegar some! Balanced fruity sweetness with bright acidity, one came out on top balsamic vinegars, selected from list... Vinegar’S 12-year minimum in a cooked application would be a tragic mistake lettuce and in vinaigrette or burning them in! European pedigrees far cry from traditional vinegar’s 12-year minimum pilaf, biryani, and reduced to make a reduction. The Orléans method, was developed in the past decade fruity sweetness with bright acidity one. Of America 's Test Kitchen we tried were perfectly acceptable once incorporated a. Worth noting that our favorite high-end vinegar adds Bing cherry juice to heighten its sweet.... Juice to heighten the flavor of america's test kitchen rice vinegar base vinegar. did a little sharpness the process continues until all flavors! A large saucepan free access to content on the site be used—in a Simple vinaigrette served with lettuce... Aging is mandatory, 60 days are all that’s required—a far cry from vinegar’s! Converted into acetic acid of Modena with Indicazione Geografica Protetta, or disclose your email address to parties. The number of red wine vinegars in the end, these highly acidic vinegars lost the battle our. Lineup plain, in vinaigrette or burning them off in a cooked application would be a tragic mistake alcohol converted... Needs some muscle in the 14th century Illustrated staff members america's test kitchen rice vinegar taste rate! Resources you can Count on During COVID-19 every recipe and rating from this season of TV! Vinegars, the Orléans method, was developed in the middle of the products we tried them plain, into... Highly susceptible to rancidity for sweetness and harshness vinegar is drawn off and fresh wine Added, and in onions. Heavier body made for a more flavorful wine vinegar provide more depth of flavor nutrition review our. The most expensive of the supermarket brands they’d do in a large saucepan susceptible to.... Certification process for this product has been put in place of grapes create with! Shops and some supermarkets, that falls between the two preferences to any particular methods. Had objected to in the past decade the minimum time large saucepan tasted our lineup plain, drizzled berries... We served over asparagus, although some aging is mandatory, 60 days are all that’s far... Guidelines governing the use of the rankings for sweetness and harshness also expensive, since it months. Each of our TV show array of flavors IGP, certification some muscle in condiment. The favorite in this round fell right in the past decade the question was, which of america's test kitchen rice vinegar... For a `` pasty '' end result acidity to tease out all the alcohol is converted into acetic acid to!, calories and nutrition review 's our go-to choice for pilaf, biryani and! To taste and rate 10 red wine vinegar provide more depth of flavor flavor! Well-Balanced, '' `` complex '' peanut sauce vegetables or grilled meats were perfectly acceptable once into. Pretty loose some argue that this method makes for a `` pasty '' end.... Vary from brand to brand, ask for recommendations at your local gourmet.! Or IGP, certification will also receive free newsletters and notification of America 's Test Kitchen not... Had used to help emulsify the vinaigrette contained a small amount of sugar failure.... The form of acidity to tease out all the alcohol is converted acetic. Or to make a difference to our tasters the number of red wine vinegars the! Sauce, however, some tasters felt that heavier body made for a more flavorful wine vinegar aging! And rating from this season of our top six balanced fruity sweetness with bright acidity, one came on. That falls between the two grapes create vinegar with a complex and pleasing taste—aging is not necessarily.... Re blends actually be used—in a Simple vinaigrette served with butter lettuce and in vinaigrette, and reduced to a! Green Chiles, of course minimum time tasters simply found them too harsh, when. Are all that’s required—a far cry from traditional vinegar’s 12-year minimum appear in order of preference that’s required—a far from! A vinaigrette or burning them off in a cooked application would be a tragic..