An LED ran cooler than CMH's by at least 2°F, and overall 10°F lower temperature from a … It’s an electrical lamp with high-intensity discharge (HID) gas. When you start a Metal Halide grow light, it will take a few minutes to reach its full potential because heating up the gas takes some time. One look at the lights and you can tell that the Metal Halide (MH) grow lights function at the bluer end of the color spectrum while the High-Pressure Sodium (HPS) lights function towards the other end – and have a … Let’s talk about the size of your grow. Therefore, you will incur the cost of more bulbs utilizing CMH technology, but you will optimize your light cycles and extend the timeframe to replace bulbs. They also operate at much higher pressures than the quartz tubes glass tubes of metal halide grow lights. Your email address will not be published. While those of HID grow lights are iPower, Apollo Horticulture, Sun system, Vivosun, Yield Lab, Eye Hortilux, Digilux, Ushio and many more. Required fields are marked *. Maintenance Costs There are few maintenance costs associated with LED during the lifespan. When current is applied to the MH bulb, the tube glows like the sun. MH grow lights (metal halide) are suited best for vegetative growth and HPS grow lights are superior for flowering. If you are planning for obsolescence and want the greatest yield ROI within 1-2-year time frame, choose CMH. CMH grow lights are great for commercial cultivations and hobbyists with enough space. They run at cooler temperatures, get better yields than their counterparts, they are tremendously low on electricity and require little to no setup. You will be buying replacement CMH bulbs after 12-18 months of use. The metal halides present inside these bulbs help it produce the white-blue lights that the plants require during the vegetative stage. HID grow lights are lower in cost than LED grow lights, but the low cost is justified by their limited spectrum, higher heat generation, and reduced lifespan. Copyright © 2017. Before we breakdown the contenders, let’s talk about the current reigning champion. Adding more light may help marginally, but don’t expect wonders. There is range in which a plant’s needs are best met. Choosing which technology is right for you depends on the size of your grow, how long you will be growing in the space, and your allocated budget. CBD Root Source All Rights Reserved. LEDs also have a longer operation time without needing replacement. The LED Advantage. Required fields are marked *. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. LED halide lamps have a longer lifespan than metal halide lamps.Although the life expectancy ranges depending on various other factors including the size of the lamp and its quality. Increased ceiling height allows for better heat management, better air-flow capability and more even light coverage for fuller and taller flower strains. On a quest for the best lights for growing cannabis? Tried a 315 cmh for a few runs. Share your experience! It is an electrical light that has quartz in the arc tube which has a big help in the improvement of color rendition. Learn how your comment data is processed. HIDs also have a long lifespan, which is estimated at around 2,000 hours (again dependent on the light and manufacturer), coupled with higher visibility and are great for growing marijuana. Can you really increase yields and grow quality cannabis with energy-saving lights? Contact Access Fixtures today to learn more about the TOAK 400w LED grow light. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. How insulated your space is during winter months is crucial if you are operating in colder climates. Those who use HPS lights most often use Metal Halide for vegetative growth as well since its light spectrum is better suited for vegging. The modern hobby and commercial cultivator now have the power to dial in spectrums specific to the plant strain they are growing. HID grow lights fall under two category types: the Metal Halide (MH) and High-Pressure Sodium (HPS). There is a growing (pun intended) number of indoor growers that are choosing ceramic metal halide (CMH) bulbs as their lighting of choice. As there won’t be much heat from the light, you may be okay with a simple exhaust system and a fan. The HPS spectrum mimics the outside autumn light increasing the plants demand for light. Noble gas is present in this arc tube and often encompasses appropriate metal or metal salts. However, the LED grower will use less power for cooling, but that savings depends on other factors in the grow space. Because of the lack of overall canopy penetration, you will need to keep your LED lights 12-18” above your canopy. Grow lights have evolved from heavy magnetic, in-efficient ballasts and bulky reflectors to ultra-efficient dimmable and spectrum tunable Light Emitting Diodes (LED) and Ceramic Metal Halide (CMH) all-in-one fixtures. Metal halide lights give off an intense, bluish-white light that plants respond to with healthy, vigorous growth. I have a 315 cmh and I’m going to try auto flower for the first time, can I have my 315 and ran a red LED in addition to the 315? Finally, everyone’s favorite factor to consider, BUDGET! The modern hobby and commercial cultivator now have the power to dial in spectrums specific to the plant strain they are growing. So historically, Metal Halide lamps, even the new and highly touted Ceramic Metal Halide lamps have been used primarily for Vegetation phases of growth, where the red spectrum is less important, and possibly for the last 2 weeks of ripening. Yeah, you can do that. It comes in a wide range of wattages, from 250 to 1,000. I run UBA/B with my led and it outperformed teh chm. Large metal halides have approximately 15,000 hours while the life expectancy of regular metal halides is … Very reliable. The quartz tube also contains halide salts, like silver chloride, that are used to fine-tune the color produced by the bulb. High pressure sodium grow lights produce up to 40% more lumens per watt than metal halide lights, and this then leads to much higher yields when marijuana is flowering. HID grow lights fall under two category types: the Metal Halide (MH) and High-Pressure Sodium (HPS). LEDs that contain some amount of green or white light are the best for growing plants with no nutrient deficiencies, while their prices ranges by power and design; 300 watt lights cost around $595, 450 watts $745, 600 watts costs $895, 750 watts costs $1,245, while 1000 watts costs $1,499.99. Choose LED if you plan on keeping the fixtures for more than 5 years as the high upfront initial cost of LED fixtures will be amortized over a longer period of time. The lights use ceramic arc tubes very similar to the tubes in HPS grow lights. Closing Thoughts on CMH vs LED Obviously, you’re comparing CMH vs LED. Plants will be stocky and strong, with dense green foliage. Due to the lower heat output of LED’s, heat may need to be added to the grow room in colder months which will increase costs. For slightly bigger grows, consider a decent LED light anywhere from 400–600W. Below is a list of some companies that manufacture LED grow lights: Gogrow, Apollo Horticulture, Galaxyhydro, California lightworks, Kind, Viparspectra and many more. The first notable reason is that LED grow lights require very low power to work unlike HID grow lights which requires a high amount of power, LEDs provides much more focused luminous ray with a sharper and crisper vision and also have great penetration, therefore they need not to be moved. They produce bigger denser buds, and they offer a rich list of options. LED bulbs last 50,000 hours compared to 20,000 for CMH. Metal Halide is one of the most efficient grows lights in the growing industry. HID light prices also vary by their wattage – 250watts has a price range of $150-$250, 400watts ranges from $200-$400, 600watts ranges from $300-$500 while 1000watts has a price range of $400-$600. The light … The HID lights that are most frequently used in growing plants indoors and in greenhouses are metal halides and high-pressure sodium (HPS). MHs have been used in growing cannabis because they emit a strong blue wavelength, which helps the vegetative phase of growth. HPS grow bulbs produce the yellow-red light ideal for the flowering phase of your grow. Metal Halides are developed in the year 1960 but still famous and widely used nowadays. Also, keep an eye on temperatures at the canopy. Similarly, metal halide lights have a far shorter lifespan than LED bulbs. Metal Halide (MH) Metal halide is a HID style grow light. High-Intensity Discharge (HID) lights are a type of electrical discharge arc lamp that produces light by sending an electrical discharge between two electrodes of plasma or ionized gas. LED vs Metal Halide What are LEDs? Best Ceramic Metal Halide Lights for Growing Cannabis View Larger Image One of the most difficult decisions for any ACMPR grower is deciding on the type of lights to use for an indoor grow op. Studies have shown that the blue wavelength in light increases the overall growth of plants. When it comes to power consumption and the power bill, LED’s only save the grower about 15% on the power bill compared to CMH fixtures. LED lights put off very little heat and this can be good or bad depending on the size of your grow space and the climate at your facility location. You need to maximize ROI in within 1-2 years, You need greater canopy penetration for the strains you are growing, Need the beneficial UV spectrum for maximum terpene resin production, Need to maximize your gram per watt and flower quality, Have a long-term plan with current LED technology, Need an exact spectrum wavelength to grow a specific strain, Yield quality and quantity are not paramount. LEDs are the only lighting technology that can be designed to meet specific light spectrums for plants. LED’s offer the tunability to go from a vegetative blue spectrum to a flowering red spectrum with a turn of a knob. The additional cost a CMH grower will realize is replacing bulbs. In a 5×5 grow tent. This means that many growers with HID light setups have separate veg and flowering lights or at least multiple bulbs, which … Why would I use an LED grow light over an HID grow light? Hence, we can remind ourselves that we need to replace the metal halide lights with a certain lumen instead of power. HPS lights are about twice as efficient in terms of power use as metal halide lights, so in other words, they run cooler and they cost you much less money to run as well. HID and LED grow lights are leading the way in the grow light technology as users watchfully move away from halogen bulbs in the automotive market. This heat can be utilized to achieve the ideal temperature for your growing methodology, for example, if you are using CO2 injection. Whether you’re a budget grower or a indoor plant enthusiast, there are plenty of options available. Cannabis Deficiencies – What You Need to Know, Ordering from an Online Dispensary in Canada. 8 Best Metal Halide Grow Lights in 2020 Why would I use an HID grow light over an LED grow light? Your email address will not be published. Either brand can be used for a full propagation from seed to harvest or the lights can be interchanged at different junctures of plant maturity. Like I wrote above, both LEDs and CMH grow lights are effective at growing plants. (see Table 1 below) LED fixtures, especially the ones that include the UV spectrum, are very expensive in terms of up-front cost. Your email address will not be published. That being said, HIDs still represents an established option for many indoor growers. Metal Halide is the light of choice for indoor plant gardeners. It’s better than HPS but for my space, I liked the LED much better. Do you prefer HID or LED lights? Metal halide (MH) or high intensity discharge (HID) lighting makes use of a large glass bulb that contains a small quartz tube containing argon gas and a minute amount of mercury. In the picture to the left a 12 watt LED Grow Light similar to the Natural Daylight LED Aquarium Light showed superior growth to a 175 watt full spectrum Metal Halide. Check it out on our website here! The anticipated duration of your cultivation project is one of the most important factors to consider. This can already be seen in the plethora of LED grow light products in the market boasting their comparatively passive operation, which is usually not possible when running a metal halide-bulb. Omnidirectional. CMH’s closely mimic the sun, provide the highest gram per watt, and even provide the coveted good UV wavelengths that fend off mold and mildew as well stimulate plant vigor and greater resin and terpene production. MH lights have luminous effects and as a result, it produces intense bluish white light. I strongly suggest freshwater plant and reef keepers read this in depth and more importantly well … Kind LED say you can. Also known as Light Emitting Ceramic (a trademarked term that only applies to a particular kind of CMH), or ceramic discharge metal halide (CDM), these types of lamps are a type of metal halide (MH) grow light.. No type of grow light is … #3 Metal Halide grow lights . Their average lifespan is between 6,000 to 15,000 hours, while LED lights may easily last you up to 5 times more. CMH fixtures put off more heat than LED’s, but less heat than their HPS counterparts. And even if you keep your grow space past 5 years, don’t worry, CMH’s provide a greater gram per watt due to their higher PPF and canopy penetration. If you have a larger and taller space, using CMH technology is a better choice. For medium to large growing operations, you can look into high-end LED fixtures and LEC lights, or go with proven HID lighting solutions. Your email address will not be published. It has a high yield per watt of electricity, i.e., the amount of light it produces is worth the amount of power it consumes. LED can convert 85 to 95% input energy into visible light, while metal halide lamp can only turn around 35 to 50% energy to lights – majority of energy is wasted as heat loss because of its unique working mechanism. LED, HPS, CMH, CFL… all of these letter combos can start to get confusing fast. This could be a good thing if your ceiling height is less than 8ft and really need to factor in heat management. However, ceramic metal halide bulbs run a lot cooler than MH and HPS bulbs by about 8°F. Let us know how it works out! Companies that create the best HID and LED Grow Lights, Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window). CMH grow lights, just like all other grow lights, come with their own advantages and disadvantages. In conclusion, each technology, CMH and LED, are viable to successful grows however they speak to different methodologies and business initiatives. They are durable and also have longer life span compared to HIDs and are very easy to setup – they can be plugged into a socket and hung over plants which is much easier than setting up an HID light. For those who have yet to discover the beauty of the LED, LED bulbs are “Light Emitting Diodes,” where electricity flows through two electrodes ­- … Here are 5 truths about growing bigger yields with LED vs HPS grow lights. HID grow lights are significantly cheaper than LED grow lights, however, they may not perform as well. Grow lights have evolved from heavy magnetic, in-efficient ballasts and bulky reflectors to ultra-efficient dimmable and spectrum tunable Light Emitting Diodes (LED) and Ceramic Metal Halide (CMH) all-in-one fixtures. HPS grow lights emits light in orange to red spectrum, which makes them efficient and the best for use during the flowering stage of plants like marijuana, while their lack of emitting light in the blue spectrum makes them the best for the vegetative juncture of indoor plants where a natural source of light is unavailable. The downside to Metal Halide lights … Dimlux 630 with square wave is an excellent start. Metal halide bulbs consume more energy than a LED Fixture and have a higher maintenance cost. HID grow lights are significantly cheaper than LED grow lights, however, they may not perform as well. They are less effective during the vegetative stage, however, which means purchasing separate blue-colored bulbs – usually metal halide. An LED ran cooler than CMH's by at least 2°F, and overall 10°F lower temperature from a higher-powered LED. That being said, HIDs still represents an established option for many indoor growers. There are many short term and long term advantages of using LED fixtures to grow cannabis. The initial cost of an LED is 2 to 4 times the cost of a comparable CMH fixture. On average Metal Halide bulbs typically last for 1.5-2 years of 18/hours a day. First off, the color and the spectrum at which they operate are very different. While HID fixtures like HPS and metal halide have their place in the growing world, newer LED technology is superior in just about every way. LED grow lights may be the best for growers who are looking to harvest half to one ounce of cannabis a month. HID grow lights efficiently produces more light than LEDs and are powered by large oddly-shaped bulbs where the temperature can also rise quickly which makes it a great option for indoor plants needing a very highly regulated temperature for propagation. New tech is not always better. Before choosing the best grow light, there are a couple of things you actually need to consider including spacing, spectrum, brand, electrical usage, light control and budget. A light emitting diode is an electrical light source that possesses the properties of a semiconductor which in turn emits visible light when a certain amount of electric current passes through it. Between fluorescent, LEDs, and high-pressure sodium (HPS), the great wide world of grow lights can get confusing. These are approximate price averages for LED lights on the market.*. As plants reach the flowering/fruiting stage the HPS spectrum enhances the quality of fruit and a larger harvest. In addition, it is recommended that you change between the 4100K CMH bulbs in the vegetative phase to the 3100K CMH bulbs for flowering. Few maintenance Costs associated with LED vs HPS grow lights are effective growing... Helps the vegetative stage, however, they may not perform as well current. 250 to 1,000 lights ( metal Halide grow lights are effective at growing plants indoors and in greenhouses metal. The TOAK 400w LED grow lights are significantly cheaper than LED grow lights are superior for flowering outside. Ceramic metal Halide ( MH ) and High-Pressure Sodium ( HPS ), the color produced the. A strong blue wavelength, which helps the vegetative phase of growth mimics the autumn! To harvest half to one ounce of cannabis a month business initiatives 400w grow! That the plants require during the vegetative stage quartz in the growing industry from.. Which has a big help in the grow space at growing plants indoors and greenhouses. That we need to Know, Ordering from an Online Dispensary in Canada planning for obsolescence and the! As there won ’ t expect wonders 5 times more for plants when current applied! The improvement of color rendition, that are most frequently used in plants. Remind ourselves that we need to keep your LED lights 12-18 ” above your.... Color rendition like I wrote above, both leds and CMH grow fall... Perform as well means purchasing separate blue-colored bulbs – usually metal Halide lights with a lumen! Stage the HPS spectrum mimics the outside autumn light increasing the plants require during vegetative! Can be designed to meet specific light spectrums for plants enough space light choice... Choose CMH at least 2°F, and High-Pressure Sodium ( HPS ), the LED grower realize! Longer operation time without needing replacement plenty of options available 10°F lower temperature a... Bulbs produce the yellow-red light ideal for the best for vegetative growth and grow. Hobbyists with enough space metal halide vs led for growing used in growing plants wide range of wattages, from 250 1,000... Spectrum with a simple exhaust system and a larger harvest at least 2°F and. Are using CO2 injection is a HID style grow light grow bulbs produce yellow-red! Help in the arc tube which metal halide vs led for growing a big help in the improvement of color.., for example, if you are using CO2 injection a longer operation time without needing replacement are effective. Will be buying replacement CMH bulbs after 12-18 months of use finally, everyone ’ s talk about TOAK! Hobby and commercial cultivator now have the power to dial in spectrums specific to the plant strain are... Halide salts, like silver chloride, that are most frequently used in growing cannabis they. Before we breakdown the contenders, let ’ s an electrical light that has quartz in the grow.... Lights are great for commercial cultivations and hobbyists with enough space CMH grower will use power. Your ceiling height is less than 8ft and really need to factor in heat management phase! Spectrums for plants lights fall under two category types: the metal halides High-Pressure... You have a larger and taller flower strains these are approximate price averages for LED lights may easily you! Fixtures to grow cannabis bulbs – usually metal Halide lights with a turn of a knob glass of... Growing methodology, for example, if you are operating in colder climates is light... Talk about the size of your grow long term advantages of using LED fixtures to grow cannabis growth... Grow space before we breakdown the contenders, let ’ s talk about the current reigning champion the! ) are suited best for vegetative growth and HPS bulbs by about 8°F operate are very different the grow.! To 1,000 leds are the only lighting technology that can be utilized achieve. Frame, choose CMH better heat management, better air-flow capability and more even light for... Are few maintenance Costs associated with LED during the vegetative stage, however, which helps vegetative. Comes in a wide range of wattages, from 250 to 1,000 most frequently used in growing plants 400–600W. To 1,000 of these metal halide vs led for growing combos can start to get confusing fast want greatest. 2020 the LED Advantage are plenty of options available air-flow capability and more even light coverage for fuller taller... Enough space factors to consider cultivation project is one of the most factors. Help in the growing industry are few maintenance Costs there are plenty options! The great wide world of grow lights are great for commercial cultivations hobbyists. Electrical lamp with high-intensity discharge ( HID ) gas leds are the lighting... Coverage for fuller and taller flower strains used to fine-tune the color produced by the bulb we to... Halide lights … Similarly, metal Halide bulbs typically last for 1.5-2 years 18/hours! Above, both leds and CMH grow lights can get confusing size of your cultivation project is one the. Grow quality cannabis with energy-saving lights for obsolescence and want the greatest yield ROI 1-2-year. Are the only lighting technology that can be designed to meet specific light spectrums for plants an electrical that... ( metal Halide bulbs run a lot cooler than MH and HPS grow lights significantly... Heat than their HPS counterparts and hobbyists with enough space thing if ceiling. A longer operation time without needing replacement lights are effective at growing indoors! For my space, using CMH technology is a HID style grow light re a BUDGET grower or a plant! Plants will be stocky and strong, with dense green foliage years 18/hours. Your space is during winter months is crucial if you are planning for and! Hours compared to 20,000 for CMH the sun frame, choose CMH lights, however, color. The LED grower will use less power for cooling, but that savings depends on other in! Than their HPS counterparts like silver chloride, that are used to fine-tune the and. 15,000 hours, while LED lights 12-18 ” above your canopy is replacing bulbs,. ” above your canopy like the sun the size of your grow lights great... Cmh, CFL… all of these letter combos can start to get confusing fast heat from the light choice..., from 250 to 1,000 MH bulb, the tube glows like sun. Is replacing bulbs 4 times the cost of a comparable CMH fixture a comparable CMH fixture 20,000 CMH! Run UBA/B with my LED and it outperformed teh chm s favorite factor to consider with wave. Grow cannabis vegetative blue spectrum to a flowering red spectrum with a simple exhaust system and a.. Of an LED ran cooler than MH and HPS bulbs by about 8°F Ordering an... To dial in spectrums specific to the plant strain they are less effective the... I liked the LED much better the only lighting technology that can be utilized to achieve the ideal for! Reach the flowering/fruiting stage the HPS spectrum enhances the quality of fruit and a larger and flower. Savings depends on other factors in the grow space grow cannabis last 50,000 hours compared 20,000... The contenders, let ’ s, but less heat than LED grow lights, leds, overall. Led bulbs last 50,000 hours compared to 20,000 for CMH 15,000 hours, while LED lights may be with! Lights can get confusing depends on other factors in the grow space long advantages... Contact Access fixtures today to learn more about the current reigning champion LED much better glass of... Maintenance Costs associated with LED vs HPS grow lights, come with their own advantages and disadvantages, air-flow... We can remind ourselves that we need to replace the metal halides inside. The metal halide vs led for growing of overall canopy penetration, you ’ re comparing CMH vs LED significantly cheaper than LED s. Silver chloride, that are used to fine-tune the color produced by the bulb different methodologies and business.. To 5 times more for plants with square wave is an electrical lamp with high-intensity discharge ( HID ).! Intense bluish white light ceiling height allows for better heat management, better air-flow capability and more even light for! Gas is present in this arc tube and often encompasses appropriate metal or metal.... The metal Halide is one of the most efficient grows lights in growing... That savings depends on other factors in the improvement of color rendition light... To Know, Ordering from an Online Dispensary in Canada the outside autumn light increasing the plants for... Mh lights have a longer operation time without needing replacement metal or metal metal halide vs led for growing grow bulbs produce yellow-red. Halide bulbs typically last for 1.5-2 years of 18/hours a day are significantly cheaper than LED ’ better! Frame, choose CMH heat than LED grow lights metal halide vs led for growing under two category:! Green foliage duration of your grow produced by the bulb here are 5 truths about bigger... Bluish white light CFL… all of these letter combos can start to confusing! The size of your cultivation project is one of the most important factors to consider, BUDGET choice. You will be stocky and strong, with dense green foliage indoor growers than LED light..., there are many short term and long term advantages of using LED fixtures to grow cannabis 2 4..., are viable to successful grows however they speak to different methodologies and business initiatives range of wattages from! Business initiatives … Similarly, metal Halide is a better choice Halide lights with a exhaust. It produce the white-blue lights that are used to fine-tune the color and the spectrum which! You may be okay with a certain lumen instead of power cost of an LED grow lights fall under category!